ISSN: Pending / Available Online Peer-Reviewed Academic Journal

Peer Review Process

The International Review of Accounting, Management and Policy (IRAMP) seeks to follow the high standards of academic quality through a fair, unbiased and transparent peer review process. Originality, relevance, academic merit, methodological appropriateness and contribution to accounting, management, business, economics, governance, policy and related areas are assessed.

The IRAMP follows a double blind peer review process, authors do not know who is reviewing their paper and reviewers do not know who is reviewing their paper. This will minimize the possibility of bias and ensure a fair and unbiased evaluation of manuscripts submitted.

Each manuscript is subjected to an initial editorial review to check for suitability within the scope of the journal, basic quality requirements, novelty and submission standards. Those manuscripts that satisfy the initial criteria can then be submitted to the appropriate, independent, and subject-matter experts for further review.

Objectives of Peer Review

The object of the peer review process is to:

  • Maintain academic excellence and quality.
  • Promote research integrity and publication ethics.
  • Evaluate the originality and importance of research.
  • Assess the suitability of the manuscript for the scope of the journal.
  • Enhance the quality, clarity and presentation of manuscripts.
  • Give positive feedback to authors.
  • Assist in the fair and objective decision making of the editorial content.
  • Promote ongoing research and practice in the academic field.

Review Criteria

Manuscripts will be reviewed based on the following:

  • Originality and novelty of the research work.
  • Appropriateness of the scope of IRAMP.
  • The quality of literature review, critical analysis.
  • Clarity and strength of the research objectives.
  • Research methodology – appropriateness.
  • Accuracy and reliability of data, analysis and interpretation.
  • Quality of discussion and conclusions.
  • The contribution of the research in an academic and practical level.
  • Organisation, clarity and style of writing.
  • Ethical compliance.
  • General contribution to accounting, management, business, economics, governance or research in policy.

Editorial Decisions

Based on reviewers' comments and Editor's judgment, one of the following decisions will be made:

  • Accept without revision.
  • Accept with slight modifications.
  • Major revisions – revise and resubmit.
  • Reject the manuscript.

Note: If requests for revision are made, the original author(s) will be asked to return the paper in the time frame provided, focusing on the comments and suggestions given by the reviewers.

The determination to publish is made in light of the academic value, originality, relevance, methodological soundness, clarity and contribution of the manuscript and review comments. The review process adheres to the principles of confidentiality, fairness, editorial independence, transparency and scholarly integrity.